Comments on: WordPress Comments: Picking the Right System for You http://wpmu.org/wordpress-comments-picking-right-system/ WordPress, Multisite & BuddyPress plugins, themes, news and reviews and special offers from the team at WPMU.org Wed, 22 May 2013 06:30:11 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.4.2 By: WPThemeDetector.com http://wpmu.org/wordpress-comments-picking-right-system/#comment-139551 WPThemeDetector.com Mon, 03 Dec 2012 18:07:54 +0000 http://wpmu.org/?p=104557#comment-139551 I agree with you, Rob. I´m using the default system right now, but I want to try CommentLuv just because of that nice feature. I agree with you, Rob. I´m using the default system right now, but I want to try CommentLuv just because of that nice feature.

]]> By: Vladislav Bailovic http://wpmu.org/wordpress-comments-picking-right-system/#comment-139540 Vladislav Bailovic Mon, 03 Dec 2012 04:03:10 +0000 http://wpmu.org/?p=104557#comment-139540 Actually, Comments Plus builds up on the default WordPress comments system, rather then replacing it with a different one. So, all comments made with Comments Plus are actually plain old WordPress comments, can be moderated in usual way in the admin area and will be shown as normal comments (i.e. actual content) on your page. Actually, Comments Plus builds up on the default WordPress comments system, rather then replacing it with a different one. So, all comments made with Comments Plus are actually plain old WordPress comments, can be moderated in usual way in the admin area and will be shown as normal comments (i.e. actual content) on your page.

]]> By: Cort Johnson http://wpmu.org/wordpress-comments-picking-right-system/#comment-139532 Cort Johnson Sun, 02 Dec 2012 00:23:48 +0000 http://wpmu.org/?p=104557#comment-139532 good post...After doing alot of work on a Forum site I find WP comments very basic...and would like to spiff them up a bit...It would have been nice to have an overview of each option :) good post…After doing alot of work on a Forum site I find WP comments very basic…and would like to spiff them up a bit…It would have been nice to have an overview of each option :)

]]> By: Fanus van Straten http://wpmu.org/wordpress-comments-picking-right-system/#comment-139524 Fanus van Straten Sat, 01 Dec 2012 06:18:21 +0000 http://wpmu.org/?p=104557#comment-139524 My million dollar question is: Which one is good for SEO since ones like Livefyre & Discuss actually runs in iframes meaning nothing for SEO. Whereas the default system is better for SEO since both the front end (readers) & the source code contains the content unlike with iframes. As for Comments Plus, I like the fact that it let's comments also appear on a commenter's FB timeline and one can customize it with a FB Dev App with your own logos, but does it also like Disqus & Livefyre run in an Iframe or are the comments actual content? I also like the comment system that comes with Jetpack but then again Jetpack comes with it's own issues so I therefore choose not to use it at all. Ultimately one's users helps building your content for you and that is why the right comment system is so important to me with SEO and all. My million dollar question is: Which one is good for SEO since ones like Livefyre & Discuss actually runs in iframes meaning nothing for SEO. Whereas the default system is better for SEO since both the front end (readers) & the source code contains the content unlike with iframes.

As for Comments Plus, I like the fact that it let’s comments also appear on a commenter’s FB timeline and one can customize it with a FB Dev App with your own logos, but does it also like Disqus & Livefyre run in an Iframe or are the comments actual content?

I also like the comment system that comes with Jetpack but then again Jetpack comes with it’s own issues so I therefore choose not to use it at all.

Ultimately one’s users helps building your content for you and that is why the right comment system is so important to me with SEO and all.

]]> By: Rob Skidmore http://wpmu.org/wordpress-comments-picking-right-system/#comment-139506 Rob Skidmore Fri, 30 Nov 2012 16:52:31 +0000 http://wpmu.org/?p=104557#comment-139506 My favorite is Andy Bailey's CommentLuv. Great functionality. My favorite thing is that it produces a link to the last blog post of every person who comments. It's a great way to build a community. My favorite is Andy Bailey’s CommentLuv. Great functionality. My favorite thing is that it produces a link to the last blog post of every person who comments. It’s a great way to build a community.

]]>